TL;DR: For most Brisbane homes, standard AS 5039-compliant SS mesh provides excellent security at a lower price. Premium screens are worth it for maximum protection on ground-floor openings or higher-risk properties.
This is the most common question I get asked: "Should I go premium or is standard mesh good enough?" After 25 years of installing both, here's my honest take. Both products have their place — the right choice depends on your home, your budget, and what you're trying to protect against.
Head-to-Head Comparison
Here's how premium stainless steel screens stack up against standard stainless steel mesh security screens across every important factor:
| Feature | Our Premium Screens | Standard SS Mesh |
|---|---|---|
| Technology | mechanical clamping (patented) | Rubber spline |
| Mesh Material | 316 marine grade SS (0.9mm) | 316 SS (0.8–0.9mm) |
| AS 5039 Compliance | Exceeds | Meets |
| Impact Resistance | Superior | Good |
| Knife Shear Resistance | Superior | Standard |
| Emergency Exit | Safe-S-Cape option | Varies by brand |
| Warranty | 10 years | 5–10 years |
| Visibility | Good | Good |
| Airflow | 70–80% | 70–80% |
| Price (hinged door) | $1,200 – $2,800 | $700 – $1,200 |
| Best For | Maximum security, high-risk | Most homes, good value |
How Our Mechanical Clamping Works
our mechanical clamping
The mesh is placed over the frame and a clamp bar is screwed down on top, mechanically locking the mesh into place. Force applied to the screen is distributed across the entire frame perimeter rather than concentrated at any single point. This is why our premium screens absorb impacts that would push standard mesh out of the spline channel.
Standard Rubber Spline
Standard screens use a rubber spline (a flexible cord) pressed into a channel in the frame to hold the mesh in tension. This is a proven system used industry-wide and passes AS 5039 testing. However, concentrated force — like a jemmy bar or a hard kick — can push the spline out of the channel at the point of impact.
When Premium Screens Are Worth the Extra Cost
Ground Floor Doors & Windows
Ground-floor openings are the primary entry point for break-ins. Our premium screens' superior impact resistance makes the biggest difference here.
Higher-Crime Areas
If your suburb has a higher burglary rate, the extra protection is worthwhile. QPS crime data can help you assess your area's risk.
Rental Properties
Tenants are generally harder on screens than owner-occupiers.
Bushfire Zones
Premium screens offer BAL-rated products that help protect against ember attack. Essential for properties in bushfire-prone areas of Brisbane's fringe suburbs.
When Standard SS Mesh Is the Smart Choice
Upper-Floor Windows
Second-storey windows are rarely targeted by intruders. Standard mesh provides insect protection and child safety without the premium price.
Low-Crime Areas
In quiet Redlands suburbs with low burglary rates, standard AS 5039-compliant mesh is more than adequate for most families.
Budget-Conscious Homeowners
If your budget is tight, standard SS mesh on every opening is far better than premium screens on the front door and nothing else.
Fly Screens Only
If you only need insect protection and airflow (no security), standard fly screen mesh is perfectly fine and much more affordable.
Pro Tip
Many of our customers take a hybrid approach: premium screens on the front door and ground-floor sliding doors (the highest-risk openings), and standard SS mesh on all windows and the back door. This gives you premium protection where it matters most while keeping the total cost reasonable. On a typical 3-bedroom home, this saves $2,000–$4,000 compared to premium screens throughout.
Other Premium Brands Worth Considering
our premium range isn't the only premium option. Here are other well-regarded brands we install in Brisbane:
Prowler Proof (ForceField)
Uses a welded frame with no screws, rivets, or clamps visible. The mesh is tensioned within a one-piece welded aluminium frame. Clean aesthetic, strong warranty, and excellent impact resistance. Price similar to premium stainless steel screens ($1,200–$2,200+ per door).
Amplimesh (SupaScreen)
One of Australia's oldest security screen manufacturers. SupaScreen uses a patented retention system and 316-grade marine stainless steel mesh. Solid mid-to-premium option with a strong warranty.
Invisi-Gard & SecureView
Both offer high-quality stainless steel mesh screens with proprietary retention systems. Invisi-Gard uses a wedge-lock system; SecureView Eclipse uses a perforated aluminium sheet rather than woven mesh for a different aesthetic. Both meet or exceed AS 5039.